Extreme Conquest in MLB The Show 25 is widely considered one of the most demanding single-player challenges in Diamond Dynasty. With strict turn-based goals, escalating difficulty levels, and zero room for mistakes early on, this mode tests not only your gameplay skill but also your planning, discipline, and MLB The Show 25 Stubs. This guide breaks down the entire Extreme Conquest map from beginning to end, focusing on what to do between games, how to manage fans, and how to minimize Legend difficulty matchups while staying on pace.

This walkthrough assumes you are using a competitive 99-overall “god squad,” which is strongly recommended. While gameplay itself is straightforward—win the games—the real challenge lies in making the right decisions on the map.

Before You Begin: Key Conquest Fundamentals

Before playing a single game, there are several core principles you must follow throughout the entire Extreme Conquest:

Always choose your fifth starter. This ensures you face the opponent’s worst pitcher.

Never attack empty territories early. Doing so wastes fans and can completely derail your first-turn objectives.

Pay close attention to goals. Every goal must be completed to finish the Extreme Program.

Take a picture of the initial map. This becomes crucial later when teams capture each other’s strongholds and labels become confusing.

With that foundation set, let’s dive into the step-by-step breakdown.

Goal #1: Conquer the East on Turn One (The Hardest Step)

Goal number one is by far the most difficult part of Extreme Conquest. On Turn One, you must capture the following strongholds:

Orioles

Red Sox

Yankees

Rays

Blue Jays

Braves

Marlins

Mets

Phillies

Nationals

This means 10 straight wins without a single loss, or you are forced into Turn Two and effectively fail the objective.

Understanding Difficulty Scaling

Difficulty is determined by the number of fans each team has. As you move through the AL East and NL East, fan totals increase, pushing games from All-Star to Hall of Fame and eventually Legend.

To complete Goal #1, you must win:

2 games on All-Star

6 games on Hall of Fame

2 games on Legend

There is no flexibility here—you must win every single one.

The Correct Order of Attack

Start in the AL East:

Orioles (All-Star)

Red Sox (Hall of Fame)

Yankees (Hall of Fame)

Rays (Hall of Fame)

Blue Jays (Legend)

Then move south to the NL East:

6. Braves (All-Star)

7. Marlins (Hall of Fame)

8. Mets (Hall of Fame)

9. Phillies (Hall of Fame)

10. Nationals (Legend)

Do not branch off. Do not enter empty tiles. Attack stronghold to stronghold only.

Because these are live series teams, not custom god squads, Legend difficulty is far more manageable than it seems. Pitch speeds are fast, but PCI sizes remain forgiving with a stacked lineup.

Once Washington falls, Goal #1 is complete—and the hardest part of Extreme Conquest is officially behind you.

Goal #2: NL Central Domination by Turn Two

Next, you must conquer the NL Central:

Cubs

Reds

Brewers

Pirates

Cardinals

Should You Steal Fans?

Stealing fans on Turn One is highly recommended. If you don’t, you’ll be forced into an extra Legend game later. Contrary to common misinformation, it does not matter if teams capture each other’s strongholds—credit still applies to the original team.

If you choose to steal fans, steal them from your next opponent. For this section, that would be the Cubs.

Expected Difficulties

Cubs: All-Star

Reds, Brewers, Pirates: Hall of Fame

Cardinals: Legend (avoidable if fan stealing is optimized)

Even if you must play one Legend game, this section is very manageable with proper fan control.

After conquering St. Louis, Goal #2 is complete.

Goal #3: NL West Control Made Easy

Goal #3 requires capturing:

Diamondbacks

Rockies

Dodgers

Padres

Giants

This is where the conquest truly begins to ease up.

Strategic Fan Steal

Steal fans from the Giants—preferably on Legend if you’re confident. Successfully stealing five fans dramatically lowers their stronghold difficulty, allowing most of this section to be played on All-Star or Veteran.

Suggested Order

Giants

Padres

Dodgers

Rockies

Diamondbacks

All games here should be comfortable, especially with a strong roster. Completing this goal also unlocks additional rewards and often completes side objectives like owning 30 million fans.

Goal #4: AL Central Confusion (Why Your Screenshot Matters)

Goal #4 includes:

White Sox

Guardians

Tigers

Royals

Twins

This is where the map can become visually misleading. Teams often capture each other’s territories, resulting in duplicate logos. This is exactly why you took a picture of the original map.

If a team recaptures one of your strongholds, don’t panic—you simply need to retake it.

Key Tip: Move Your Fans

After reinforcing, always move excess fans forward. Forgetting to move fans can lock you out of easy attacks and force unnecessary high-difficulty games.

Most of these games can be played on All-Star or Veteran once your fan count is high enough.

Once the Twins’ territory is captured, Goal #4 is complete.

Goal #5: AL West Cleanup (On or Before Turn Five)

Final strongholds include:

Astros

Angels

Athletics

Mariners

Rangers

The good news? If you’re still on Turn Four, you can skip stealing fans entirely and play everything on Veteran.

Reinforce, attack efficiently, and clean up the remaining strongholds with minimal resistance buy MLB The Show 25 Stubs.

Once Texas falls for the final time, every stronghold on the map has been conquered.

Final Step: Capturing Empty Territories

With all goals complete, the only thing left is filling in empty tiles. This is a simple cleanup:

Reinforce wisely

Move fans strategically

Avoid overextending

Collect hidden packs along the way

No difficult games remain, and you can finish the map comfortably.

Final Thoughts: Extreme Conquest Conquered

Extreme Conquest in MLB The Show 25 is less about raw gameplay skill and more about discipline, planning, and patience. If you follow the correct order, avoid empty territories early, steal fans wisely, and always choose your fifth starter, this challenge becomes not only manageable but rewarding.

Yes, disconnects can happen. Yes, mistakes are costly. But with the strategies outlined above, you can conquer Extreme Conquest efficiently, minimize Legend difficulty games, and walk away with every reward the program has to offer.

Victory is yours—and now, the map belongs to you.